Should Ruben Amorim Take Marcus Rashford Back at Manchester United Next Season? 🤔
As Manchester United prepares for a potential rebuild under Rúben Amorim, one of the biggest questions looming over Old Trafford isn’t about new signings — it’s about whether to welcome Marcus Rashford back into the fold.
The once-brilliant academy star, now 28, has endured a turbulent spell both on and off the pitch. Rashford’s form has dipped dramatically since his breakout 2021–22 campaign, and his attitude has come under scrutiny after a series of off-field controversies and a perceived lack of discipline. Yet, despite the criticism, his raw talent and deep connection to United’s DNA still make him one of the most intriguing questions of Amorim’s upcoming tenure.
⚽ The Case For Rashford’s Return
There’s no denying Rashford’s ability when he’s at his best. Under Amorim — a coach known for revitalizing attacking players and building systems based on pressing, pace, and fluid movement — Rashford could rediscover the fire that once made him one of Europe’s most dangerous forwards.
- Amorim’s system suits Rashford: At Sporting CP, Amorim’s 3-4-3 relied on dynamic wingers who pressed high and exploited spaces behind defenders. Rashford’s speed and directness could thrive in that setup.
- A redemption arc: Every great club loves a comeback story. Rashford, a local hero from Wythenshawe, could re-establish himself as the emotional heartbeat of the squad — if he’s willing to work for it.
- Financial sense: Instead of offloading him at a low value amid poor form, keeping Rashford could prove smarter — especially if Amorim can restore his confidence and market value.
đźš« The Case Against Bringing Rashford Back
However, there’s a growing argument that it might be time to cut ties. Amorim’s biggest strength is discipline and structure — qualities Rashford has reportedly struggled with under Ten Hag.
- Questionable commitment: Rashford’s off-field behavior — including missed training and nightlife incidents — has been a point of concern. Amorim, who demands professionalism above all, might view him as a distraction.
- Team balance: Amorim prefers versatile, tactically intelligent forwards who press aggressively. Rashford’s defensive work rate has often been criticized.
- New direction: A fresh start under Amorim could mean moving on from underperforming stars to build a younger, hungrier team that fits his vision.
🔍 What Amorim Might Do
If history is any guide, Amorim will judge Rashford based on attitude first, performance second. At Sporting, he famously benched key players who failed to meet his standards — even at the cost of short-term results.
Should Rashford show humility and buy into the collective ethos, Amorim could easily use him as a central figure in United’s attack. If not, he might become one of the first high-profile exits of the new era.
