C. “THIS IS WHAT GREATNESS LOOKS LIKE” — Tony Gonzalez DEFENDS Andy Reid AMID BACKLASH
As the Kansas City Chiefs navigate an offseason filled with scrutiny and change, one familiar debate has resurfaced — and it has drawn a sharp response from one of the most respected voices in franchise history.
Tony Gonzalez has publicly come to the defense of longtime special teams coordinator Dave Toub, pushing back against what he described as “lazy” and “short-sighted” criticism from so-called fans who only appear when the team is winning.
“If you’re saying Dave Toub ruined an entire season,” Gonzalez said, “then you’re not a real fan. This man has led the Chiefs for 13 seasons. You don’t erase that because things didn’t go perfectly.”
The comments come after renewed backlash toward Toub following another uneven year for Kansas City’s special teams unit. Some critics have questioned why the Chiefs would bring Toub back despite what they see as a steady decline in performance — framing the decision as “scary” and warning it could define whether Andy Reid is willing to make real changes within his staff.
That narrative hasn’t sat well with Gonzalez.
To him, the criticism ignores context, history, and accountability. Toub has been part of the Chiefs’ coaching staff since 2013, contributing to multiple Super Bowl runs and consistently ranking among the league’s most respected special teams minds. For over a decade, Kansas City’s margin-defining moments — field position, coverage discipline, and situational execution — have often been strengths, not liabilities.
Gonzalez took particular issue with what he labeled “fair-weather fandom.”
“Real fans understand cycles,” he said. “They understand that football isn’t one unit, one coach, or one season. Dave Toub didn’t suddenly forget how to coach. And pretending he did because it fits a narrative is unfair.”
While it’s true that Kansas City’s special teams have faced struggles, Gonzalez emphasized that pointing fingers at one coach oversimplifies a much larger picture — injuries, roster turnover, and systemic pressure created by years of sustained success.
Inside the organization, sources suggest Reid values continuity and trust, especially with assistants who have proven their worth over time. That doesn’t mean changes won’t happen — but it does mean decisions won’t be driven by online outrage.
For Gonzalez, the message is simple: respect the body of work.
“You don’t build a dynasty by panicking,” he said. “You build it by standing by people who’ve earned it.”
As Kansas City evaluates its next steps, the debate around Dave Toub will likely continue. But with franchise legends like Tony Gonzalez drawing a line in the sand, one thing is clear — not all criticism carries the same weight, and not all fans see the game the same way.
In a city that has learned what sustained excellence looks like, patience — not outrage — may once again be the test.
