Arlington, TX. November 23, 2025
The Dallas Cowboys found themselves at the center of another officiating storm on Sunday after a controversial “roughing the kicker” penalty shifted the momentum of their matchup against the Philadelphia Eagles. What should have been a defensive stop with the Cowboys leading 7–0 quickly unraveled into a moment that changed the entire flow of the first half.
The sequence began on a routine 4th-and-10 punt by Philadelphia. Dallas linebacker Marist Liafau charged in cleanly and appeared to tip the ball before making contact with the punter. Under NFL rules, touching the football negates “roughing the kicker.” Video angles showed Liafau’s hand clearly redirecting the flight of the ball. Yet the flag still flew, stunning the Cowboys sideline and igniting immediate confusion throughout AT&T Stadium.
What followed proved even more costly. Despite Liafau frantically signaling that he had touched the punt, the Cowboys chose not to challenge the call. Coaches hesitated. The moment slipped away. And Philadelphia seized the opportunity. Just minutes later, the Eagles capitalized on the extended drive and punched in a touchdown that swung the game to 14–0 — a massive emotional and strategic swing that Dallas never fully recovered from.
The missed challenge became the story of the sequence. Fans, analysts and former players all pointed out that slow-motion replays made the tip obvious. One longtime NFC evaluator put it bluntly,
“If you challenge that, the flag comes off. That’s a momentum killer for Dallas, plain and simple.” Instead the penalty stood, and the Eagles turned controversy into points.
Roughing the kicker was called on the Cowboys despite replay appearing to show that Dallas got a hand on the ball.pic.twitter.com/zX1rQ8mhbT — FOX Sports: NFL (@NFLonFOX) November 23, 2025
For the Cowboys the frustration was layered. They believed they had earned a stop. They believed the officiating crew missed a clear technical detail. And they believed their own sideline allowed a pivotal moment to pass without action. In a division race this tight, mistakes like that echo far beyond a single drive.
Philadelphia walked away with the scoreboard advantage. Dallas walked away with a lingering sense that an avoidable officiating error — and a missed decision on their own part — altered the complexion of the night.
Stay tuned to ESPN!
